Anunţă-mă când se modifică Fişă act Comentarii (0) Trimite unui prieten Tipareste act

DECIZIE Nr

DECIZIE   Nr. XII din 21 noiembrie 2005

ACT EMIS DE:        INALTA CURTE DE CASATIE SI JUSTITIE - SECTIILE UNITE

ACT PUBLICAT IN:    MONITORUL OFICIAL  NR. 119 din  8 februarie 2006


 

     Dosar nr. 12/2005
     Sub presedintia doamnei Lidia Barbulescu, vicepresedintele Inaltei Curti de Casatie si Justitie,
     Inalta Curte de Casatie si Justitie constituita in Sectii Unite, conformandu-se dispozitiilor art. 25 lit. a) din Legea nr. 304/2004 privind organizarea judiciara, republicata, s-a intrunit in vederea examinarii recursului in interesul legii, declarat de procurorul general al Parchetului de pe langa Inalta Curte de Casatie si Justitie, cu privire la caile de atac impotriva incheierilor pronuntate in cursul urmaririi penale, in prima instanta si in apel, referitoare la revocarea, inlocuirea sau incetarea arestarii preventive.
     Sectiile Unite au fost constituite cu respectarea cerintelor legii, fiind prezenti 95 de judecatori din totalul de 110 judecatori aflati in functie.
     Procurorul general al Parchetului de pe langa Inalta Curte de Casatie si Justitie a fost reprezentat de procurorul Nicoleta Eucarie.
     Reprezentantul procurorului general al Parchetului de pe langa Inalta Curte de Casatie si Justitie a sustinut recursul in interesul legii, cerand sa fie admis in sensul de a se stabili ca incheierea prin care se dispune, in cursul urmaririi penale, respingerea cererii de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive, precum si incheierea data, in cursul judecatii in prima instanta si in apel, prin care se respinge cererea privind revocarea, inlocuirea sau incetarea arestarii preventive, nu pot fi atacate, separat, cu recurs.

     SECTIILE UNITE,
deliberand asupra recursului in interesul legii, constata urmatoarele:
     In legatura cu aplicarea dispozitiilor art. 140-3 alin. 1 si ale art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala, s-a constatat ca instantele judecatoresti nu au un punct de vedere unitar, pronuntandu-se in mod diferit cu privire la posibilitatea atacarii, separat, cu recurs a incheierii pronuntate in cursul urmaririi penale, precum si in cursul judecatii in prima instanta si in apel, prin care a fost respinsa cererea de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive.
     Astfel, unele instante s-au pronuntat in sensul ca aceasta incheiere poate fi atacata separat cu recurs, in temeiul art. 140-3 alin. 1 si al art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala.
     Alte instante, dimpotriva, s-au pronuntat in sensul ca o atare incheiere nu poate fi atacata, separat, cu recurs, intrucat art. 140-3 alin. 1 si art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala nu prevad o cale de atac separata impotriva incheierii pronuntate in cursul urmaririi penale, in prima instanta sau in apel, prin care a fost respinsa cererea de revocare, inlocuire ori incetare a arestarii preventive.
     Aceste din urma instante au procedat corect.
     Potrivit art. 140-3 alin. 1 din Codul de procedura penala, incheierea prin care se dispune, in timpul urmaririi penale, luarea masurii arestarii preventive, incheierea prin care se dispune revocarea, inlocuirea, incetarea sau prelungirea arestarii preventive si incheierea de respingere a propunerii de arestare preventiva pot fi atacate cu recurs de catre invinuit sau inculpat si de procuror la instanta superioara in termen de 24 de ore de la pronuntare, pentru cei prezenti, si de la comunicare, pentru cei lipsa. Din prevederile acestui text de lege rezulta ca incheierea prin care nu se dispune revocarea, inlocuirea sau incetarea arestarii preventive, ci se respinge cererea de revocare, inlocuire ori incetare a acestei masuri preventive, nu poate fi atacata cu recurs in conditiile art. 140-3 alin. 1 din Codul de procedura penala.
     Cu privire la calea de atac impotriva incheierii pronuntate de instanta in cursul judecatii privind masurile preventive, art. 141 alin. 1 din Codul de procedura penala prevede ca incheierea data in prima instanta si in apel, prin care se dispune luarea, revocarea, inlocuirea, incetarea sau mentinerea unei masuri preventive ori prin care se constata incetarea de drept a arestarii preventive, poate fi atacata separat cu recurs de procuror sau de inculpat. Prin urmare, art. 141 nu prevede o cale de atac separata si impotriva incheierii date in prima instanta sau in apel, prin care se respinge cererea de revocare, inlocuire ori incetare a unei masuri preventive, inclusiv a arestarii preventive, si, ca atare, aceasta incheiere nu poate fi atacata separat cu recurs, in conditiile art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala.
     In raport cu prevederile art. 140-3 alin. 1 si ale art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala, a recunoaste calea de atac a recursului separat, impotriva incheierii pronuntate in cursul urmaririi penale, in prima instanta sau in apel, prin care se respinge cererea de revocare, inlocuire ori incetare a arestarii preventive, inseamna a recunoaste o cale de atac neprevazuta de lege, ceea ce ar fi contrar art. 23 alin. (7) si art. 129 din Constitutie, potrivit carora incheierile instantei privind masura arestarii preventive sunt supuse cailor de atac prevazute de lege, iar impotriva hotararilor judecatoresti partile interesate si Ministerul Public pot exercita caile de atac, in conditiile legii. In acelasi timp s-ar incalca art. 385-1 alin. 2 din Codul de procedura penala, in temeiul caruia incheierile care nu pot fi atacate, separat, cu recurs, potrivit legii, pot fi atacate cu recurs numai odata cu sentinta sau decizia recurata.
     Ratiunile pentru care in art. 140-3 alin. 1 si art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala nu a fost reglementat recursul impotriva incheierilor prin care, in cursul urmaririi penale sau in cursul judecatii in prima instanta ori in apel, a fost respinsa cererea de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive constau, pe de o parte, in faptul ca o noua cerere de revocare, inlocuire ori incetare a arestarii preventive, pentru motive noi, poate fi formulata oricand in cursul urmaririi penale sau al judecatii.
     Pe de alta parte, prin dispozitiile art. 146 alin. 12, art. 149-1 alin. 13, art. 159 alin. 8, art. 160-a alin. 2 si art. 160-b din Codul de procedura penala, se asigura atat controlul judiciar imediat, realizat de catre o instanta ierarhic superioara, asupra legalitatii si temeiniciei arestarii preventive in cursul urmaririi penale si al judecatii, cat si verificarea periodica a legalitatii si temeiniciei acestei masuri preventive in cursul judecatii.
     Totodata, lipsa posibilitatii de a ataca, separat, cu recurs incheierea pronuntata in cursul urmaririi penale sau in cursul judecatii in prima instanta si in apel, prin care a fost respinsa cererea de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive, nu contravine art. 5 paragraful 4 din Conventia pentru apararea drepturilor omului si a libertatilor fundamentale, potrivit caruia "orice persoana lipsita de libertatea sa prin arestare sau detinere are dreptul sa introduca un recurs in fata unui tribunal, pentru ca acesta sa statueze intr-un termen scurt asupra legalitatii detinerii sale si sa dispuna eliberarea sa daca detinerea este ilegala". Asa cum rezulta din jurisprudenta Curtii Europene a Drepturilor Omului, art. 5 paragraful 4 din Conventie nu garanteaza dreptul la o cale de atac impotriva hotararilor privitoare la arestarea preventiva, ci garanteaza un grad de jurisdictie, reprezentat de o instanta independenta, pentru luarea, prelungirea sau mentinerea arestarii preventive.

     In consecinta, in temeiul dispozitiilor art. 25 lit. a) din Legea nr. 304/2004 privind organizarea judiciara, republicata, si ale art. 414-2 din Codul de procedura penala, urmeaza a se admite recursul in interesul legii declarat de procurorul general al Parchetului de pe langa Inalta Curte de Casatie si Justitie si a se stabili ca incheierea prin care se dispune, in cursul urmaririi penale, respingerea cererii de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive, precum si incheierea data in prima instanta si in apel, prin care se dispune respingerea cererii de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive, nu pot fi atacate, separat, cu recurs.

     PENTRU ACESTE MOTIVE
     In numele legii
     DECID:

     Admit recursul in interesul legii declarat de procurorul general al Parchetului de pe langa Inalta Curte de Casatie si Justitie.
     In aplicarea dispozitiilor art. 140-3 alin. 1 si ale art. 141 din Codul de procedura penala, stabilesc:
     1. Incheierea prin care se dispune, in cursul urmaririi penale, respingerea cererii de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive nu poate fi atacata, separat, cu recurs.
     2. Incheierea data in prima instanta si in apel, prin care se dispune respingerea cererii de revocare, inlocuire sau incetare a arestarii preventive nu poate fi atacata, separat, cu recurs.
     Obligatorie, potrivit art. 414-2 alin. 2 din Codul de procedura penala.
     Pronuntata in sedinta publica, astazi, 21 noiembrie 2005.

     VICEPRESEDINTELE INALTEI CURTI DE CASATIE SI JUSTITIE,
     LIDIA BARBULESCU

     Magistrat-asistent sef,
     Victoria Maftei

    



SmartCity5

COMENTARII la Decizia 12/2005

Momentan nu exista niciun comentariu la Decizia 12 din 2005
Comentarii la alte acte
ANONIM a comentat Decretul 276 1997
    I Almost Lost All My Fonte To Divorce Get Help With WRAITH HACKERS RECOVERY Did you know that there are professional private investigators who can help you obtain information on your spouse, including texts/calls and erased messages if he/she attempts to act smart and deletes them? This can aid you with your divorce process, which the lawyer will require. Contact Wraith Hacker Recovery. They can follow their location using live GPS, monitor text messages, WhatsApp, and Snapchat, recover deleted conversations, and handle any issues. All of this is done with no traces. They will show you how they will hack and allow you access to SPY on their phone. https://wraithhackers.com/ https://t.me/wraithhacks Whatsapp number: +1 (667) 349-1550 Write to wraithhacks@protonmail.com
ANONIM a comentat Rectificare 158 2015
    ASSISTANCE IN HELPING RECOVERY LOST CRYPTO FUNDS Hire WRAITH HACKERS RECOVERY I’d like to share my experience after falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam and losing $11,500 amount of money. I had invested in what I believed was a legitimate platform, but everything changed when I attempted to withdraw my funds and encountered unexpected problems. During this difficult situation, I came across Wraith Hackers Recovery and decided to reach out for assistance. I’m grateful that I did. Their team was professional, knowledgeable, and supportive throughout the process, taking the time to explain the steps involved and guide me through the recovery efforts. With their assistance, I was able to recover $9,978 of the funds I had lost. htt ps:// wraithhackers. com/ htt ps:// t.me / wraithhacks Whatsapp number: +1 (667) 349-1550 Write to wraithhacks @ protonmail. com
ANONIM a comentat Ordin 335 2021
    Legitimate Crypto Recovery Companies 2026 Hire WRAITH HACKERS RECOVERY At Wraith Hackers Recovery, the team is committed to providing professional cryptocurrency recovery support through advanced technology, expertise, and transparent communication. They aim to keep up with developments in the field while helping clients understand their available options. If you’ve lost cryptocurrency through a scam or fraud, you can contact Wraith Hackers Recovery to learn more about their services, recovery process, and requirements. https://wraithhackers.com/ https://t.me/wraithhacks Whatsapp number: +1 (667) 349-1550 Write to wraithhacks@protonmail.com.
ANONIM a comentat Ordin 38 2002
    HIRE A LICENSED CRYPTO RECOVERY EXPERT Hire WRAITH HACKERS RECOVERY I’m sharing my personal experience of how I sought help after becoming a victim of a cryptocurrency scam. I had invested a significant amount of money through what I believed was a legitimate platform, but everything changed when I attempted to withdraw my funds and encountered difficulties. Unsure of what to do next, I began looking for assistance and came across Wraith Hackers Recovery. I decided to contact them to learn more about my options, and I’m grateful that I did. Throughout the process, I received guidance and support that helped me better understand the steps involved in attempting to recover my lost funds. With their assistance, I was able to recover a substantial portion of the money I had lost. The experience was extremely stressful, but having support throughout the process made a significant difference for me. https://wraithhackers.com/ https://t.me/wraithhacks Whatsapp number: +1 (667) 349-1550 Write to wraithhacks@protonmail.com.
ANONIM a comentat Ordin 1287 2007
    usually don’t comment on these threads but this one hit close. Short version: hired the dark web ethical hacking and cybersecurity firm CyberH4cks. com paid about $55k USD, never used a single file in court, still worth it. Longer version: my ex was telling everyone (including the kids) that I cheated, that she was the victim, etc. Meanwhile I had suspicions but nothing concrete. What made the military grade hackers at CyberH4cks different from local PIs was that they weren’t limited to Instagram screenshots and parking-lot photos. A lot of modern infidelity leaves digital exhaust in places most people never look encrypted comms, burner accounts, stuff that lives off the regular web. we eventually opened a case with them on telegram with cellphone number +1 551 414 8634 (@cyberh4cks) They explained (in plain English) that some of that intelligence only exists in dark-web forums and data brokers you access via Tor / onion routing. Again they did that part, not me. I never even asked for the raw material. Didn’t want it. All that mattered was that my ex found out an independent forensic team had already pieced together the timeline. After that? Completely different person. Cooperative. Reasonable. Quiet. The kids stopped hearing nonsense. Divorce wrapped fast. That’s what I paid for.
ANONIM a comentat Decretul 360 2017
    How Marv Web Can Assist in Cryptocurrency Recovery The recovery of cryptocurrencies has been revolutionized by MARV Web. They are incredibly quick and effective, making sure that every procedure goes without a hitch. Their customer support is always accessible and friendly, and their service is unmatched in terms of dependability. I've never felt more confident or comfortable about my ability to properly recover my cryptocurrency holdings. Because of their exceptional quickness, dependability, and effectiveness in bitcoin recovery, MARV Web stands out in the industry and is highly recommended! They can be reached at: Email address: marv.web@mail.com WhatsApp;+601126730582 Web;https://marvweb9.wixsite.com/marv-web-crypto-expe
ANONIM a comentat Legea 266 2001
    How Marv Web Can Assist in Cryptocurrency Recovery The recovery of cryptocurrencies has been revolutionized by MARV Web. They are incredibly quick and effective, making sure that every procedure goes without a hitch. Their customer support is always accessible and friendly, and their service is unmatched in terms of dependability. I've never felt more confident or comfortable about my ability to properly recover my cryptocurrency holdings. Because of their exceptional quickness, dependability, and effectiveness in bitcoin recovery, MARV Web stands out in the industry and is highly recommended! They can be reached at: Email address: marv.web@mail.com WhatsApp;+601126730582 Web;https://marvweb9.wixsite.com/marv-web-crypto-expe
ANONIM a comentat Decizia 220 2018
    Buongiorno E-mail: giovannidinatale1954@­gmail.­com Offerte individuali in denaro da 2.000 a 5.200.000, con un tasso di interesse è rimborsabile del 3% in un periodo compreso tra 2 e 30 anni. Condizioni ragionevoli se la mia offerta ti interessa contattami di più rapidamente per discutere le modalità e documenti da fornire. giovannidinatale1954@­gmail.­com
ANONIM a comentat Decizia 220 2018
    Buongiorno E-mail: giovannidinatale1954@­gmail.­com Offerte individuali in denaro da 2.000 a 5.200.000, con un tasso di interesse è rimborsabile del 3% in un periodo compreso tra 2 e 30 anni. Condizioni ragionevoli se la mia offerta ti interessa contattami di più rapidamente per discutere le modalità e documenti da fornire. giovannidinatale1954@­gmail.­com
ANONIM a comentat Decretul 358 1948
    What type of loan do you need? Personal loan Car loan Refinancing Mortgage Business capital (start or expand your business) Have you lost hope and think that there is no way out, but your financial problems are still not gone? Do not hesitate to contact us for possible business cooperation. Contact us (WhatsApp) number +918131851434 contact email id : sumitihomelend@gmail.com Mr. Damian Sumiti
Alte acte pe aceeaşi temă cu Decizia 12/2005
Coduri postale Prefixe si Coduri postale din Romania Magazin si service calculatoare Sibiu